Skip to main content
Observer Ethical awards Winners 2011

YouGen Blog

A point of view: The problem with EPCs

Posted by Tim Tucker on 17 October 2018 at 10:13 am

If you want to update an out of date or expired Energy Performance Certificate (EPC), you may be in for a nasty surprise. You may get a worse one, even if you have added numerous improvements to your house.

Five years ago, our children told us to downsize. So we did. We bought a 5 year old south-facing house, to which we added a 4 kWh solar PV array. We also added an Energy Recovery gadget (also known as a power diverter or Solar PV optimiser) which heats our hot water from the solar PV throughout the year, so we do not buy gas for hot water. Apart from that we added a porch before the front door which reduced heat loss, and an unheated conservatory on the south side which is thermally insulated from the rest of the house. However the conservatory is capable of heating the whole house on a sunny day in winter if we open the French window from the sitting room. In addition, extra roof insulation was added to the roof space, and all the lighting was changed to low energy.

But our energy suppliers would not believe our lower consumption, so we had to call in the ombudsman, who ruled in our favour, and we got over £800 back. We then changed our energy supplier.

But the biggest change came when we installed batteries in February 2017. Since then we have not drawn any electricity from the grid, which meant that our new energy supplier reckoned that our meter was faulty. They changed the meter, and we are still not buying electricity.

The original EPC expired in August 2018, so, as we are both in our late 80s, we applied for a new one to save our children trouble when we leave this world.

The assessor came, and duly awarded us a rating of 75. This was lower than the original rating of 77, but still a C rating. So I complained, and 9 days later I found that my rating had been changed to 90. 90 is a B, and just two points below an A rating.

Looking into the reasons for this sudden change, the only ones I could find were that the porch and the conservatory had been treated as extra space to be heated, instead of extra insulation. The extra roof insulation had not been taken into account either.

Nevertheless the latest EPC still says that my “Estimated energy costs for this home” at £1,887 over 3 years. This is actually just over twice what I am actually paying my energy supplier, where I am £235 in credit. But you get a ready answer to this: The costs of energy are going to go up, and, “the figures are always based on the same assumption – that the property will be heated for 9 hours per day for 5 days per week, and 16 hours per day for 2 days per week.” In other words, for a house inhabited by working families. But my wife and I are retired, and live in the house almost all the time. So this argument does not add up either. The other part of the assumption is that the living room will be heated to 21 degrees and other living spaces to 18 degrees.  If the house is heated to a lower temperature than this assumption will not give an accurate calculation

But the biggest reason for the difference is that the “methodology” used by assessors is that neither the Powerflow batteries, nor the Powerflow Energy Recovery System I have installed are accepted by the “methodology”. Yet putting those two items into my system have given me the greatest energy savings of them all.

So if, or when, the government recognises batteries, we ought to get an A.

Carefully adding to your house’s eco credentials can pay large dividends. Before putting in batteries, I worked out that my Return on Investment (ROI) was just over 15%, which is better than you get anywhere else at the moment. But the ROI after putting in my Powerflow batteries must be even better, because we have now almost completely eliminated our buying of electricity.

EPCs, which are legal documents, do not realise this. You need them when buying, selling or renting houses. You also need an EPC with a D rating or better if you want to claim Feed in Tariff after installing solar PV.

In the latter case, do not do as I did. Do not ask the estate agent who sold you the house for an EPC. Mine charged me 3 times the going rate, and I ended up with an assessor who gave a wrong reading. Instead, ask the firm you have chosen to install your solar PV, or go to the Government’s register of assessors to be found at https://www.epcregister.com/searchAssessor.html

 

Here at YouGen we will ocassionally accept blog contributions from our readers if they are interesting, relevant and abide by our writing guidelines. These articles represent the views of individuals and do not necesserily reflect those of YouGen or NEF. 

 

About the author:

The author is one of our older contributors. In 1961, after 9 years in the heat of India, Tim bought a plot of land in England and employed an architect to put a house on it. When he asked the architect to consider two inches of fibreglass in the roof space and some double glazing, he was told not to waste his money. ‘It is much cheaper, just to turn the heat up.’  After that experience he has been obsessed by energy conservation.

Working since in winter in places such as Kazakhstan, Estonia , Finland and Romania has not changed Tim's desire to come home to warmth, and to lower heating bills.

If you have a question about anything in the above blog, please ask it in the comments section below.

Like this blog? Keep up to date with our free monthly newsletter

Comments

10 comments - read them below or add one

JCapirote

JCapiroteComment left on: 14 November 2018 at 9:10 am

It is also interesting to note that when I installed my 4kw solar PV panels I had some work to do to get the house down to band D from E. In my specific case I had NO heating in the house at all as the gas boiler had expired, it was already a reconditioned warm air boiler when it was installed in the 1960s and I refused to replace it with an overpriced gas fed boiler system. 

Anyway, because I had no heating I was penalised and actually managed to improve the rating dramatically by ‘installing’ some £20 infra-red heaters from a local hardware store. 1 in each bedroom and 1 in the lounge did the trick along with an extra 4 inches of insulation in my loft taking the total depth to 10”.

It was deemed more energy efficient to have ‘installed’ the heaters than not, crazy!

I did not see the point in spending £2-3,000 on a condenser boiler heating system I had no intention of using to get a few pounds back in the increased production payment from the FIT

report abuse

stevesmith1

stevesmith1Comment left on: 6 November 2018 at 10:23 am

Aol is one of the best web portal and online service provider now this time, if you are Aol user. You are facing more issues like aol login, aol password recovery, aol account recovery, reset aol password then you can get help aol customer service and customer support no- 18447978692.

As you know that aol account login any system and laptop and you forget the sign out aol account then you reset the password and you are facing more difficulty you may get help aol customer support we provide best customer support service.

 

report abuse

simon

simonComment left on: 5 November 2018 at 7:16 am

I agree that EPCs are a blunt tool - they are based on rdSAP afterall where 'rd' stands for reduced dataset. The average home owner would be up in arms if they had to pay someone to do the full SAP assessment every time.

We eco-retrofitted a mid 50s brick built flat circa 5 years ago that had an EPC 'C' rating - 75.

Whilst I didn't get any certification at the time, out of curiosity I did get an airtightness test which came out at 0.75ACH averaged.

Due to a change in circumstances we are about to rent the flat so we decided needed a new EPC as the old one didn't reflect the 'eco' credentials we are trying to promote. Unfortunately most of the country isn't concerned about the state of the world but considers only the apparent 'cost of living' and not the big picture costs; even the estate agents are hesitant about an increased rental figure even through we have 4KW of photovoltaic panels on the roof and have not had the central heating on for the last four winters...

Anyway, we were lucky to get an 'A' rating (96) but mainly because we could show the paperwork for all the insulation matrials used and he could measure the 400mm of wool in the loft and see the u-values for that on the paperwork. However, when we said we were expecting an 'A' he said 'those are usually only for new homes' - as if those are built to high standards of air-tightness and insulation!

I also used the assessor register to find someone but I had to pay £65 pounds for the EPC (our agent did suggest it would be cheaper to find our own) and that was the same price that another person quoted in this area. However, I guess these people have to make a living and also have costs like training, certification and acrediation services.

So, a good news story in the end, we went up by 21 points - just need to find some eco tenants to rent the home :-)

report abuse

davidjones

davidjonesComment left on: 2 November 2018 at 6:57 am

He fastest way to contact yahoo, the best Yahoo phone number available and their other best contact.call yahoo customer service and for general inquiries.

Call Toll Free: (1844-797-8692)

Go to the Yahoo Mail Quick Fix tool.

Select the problem you're having.

Enter an alternate email address, different from the one you're trying to fix.

Enter the verification code shown.

Click Create Request

http://softproserv.com/yahoo-customer-service/   https://i98.servimg.com/u/f98/19/00/72/84/yahoo_11.png

report abuse

davidjones

davidjonesComment left on: 2 November 2018 at 6:55 am

Get Support From Our Experts or Search Our Help Center. Easily Import Old Emails. Unsubscribe Suggestions.

Gmail is a free advertising support email service , google mail servers automatically scan email multiple purpose.

Gmail Customer Service for free google gmail password recovery & email technical glitches. Get online Gmail Support by Certified Experts to change gmail password" Call Toll Free(1844-797-8692)

http://softproserv.com/gmail-customer-service/

https://i98.servimg.com/u/f98/19/00/72/84/gmail_11.jpg

report abuse

Slots

SlotsComment left on: 31 October 2018 at 4:03 pm

I'm 70 and I agree about EPC and how they are produced. We are about to downsize and move so I got an online company that deals with freelance assessors to to provide our first ever EPC. The cost was £35 for the EPC and £20 for the floor plan. The property is now on sale online and we avoided the estate agents hefty mark up.

We got a C 75 rating at 159 kWh/m2 just short of a B. When I challenged the assessor by saying our Primary Energy per Square Metre of Floor Area (kWh/m2) was working out at 112 kWh/m2 he said it was the assumptions in the rating process that were causing the difference.

I have kept a record of Gas and Lec on a spreadsheet since 1983 The graph of kWh/m2 shows a straight line decrease which hit the EPC 159 mark back in 2002. The way we acheived further falls was by replacing engergy hungry appliances by more efficient ones. All our refrigeration has A+++ ratings.

Last year 2017 we replaced a state of the art Dutch solo gas condensing boiler installed in 1999 with the same make only this time it was a combi boiler with an IoT thermostat. This boiler has an inbuilt cold water preheater from flue gasses that makes hot water heat recovery about 6% better than it might otherwise be.

I have a small scale solar install of about 800W that dumps excess energy through a solar hot water device into an oil filled radiator meaning nothing goes back to the grid. I can manually switch the number of panels in use. At the new house I will invest in batteries and larger PV which should lower the Lec consumption. Gas heating though is the largest part of of the present 112 kWh/m2 being consumed.

report abuse

Toff

ToffComment left on: 31 October 2018 at 3:29 pm

Add zoning (Honeywell Evohome) then,  for EPC purposes, energy savings will largely be ignored as the Database treats Evohome as just two zones with 3 TRVs. The bottom line is that if it hasn’t been tested by BRE then the EPC software will treat the system as unspecificied (generic). I was 1 point away from an ‘A’ EPC. Evohome might just as well have been left in its box. Fortunately, my buyer was fascinated by it.

report abuse

Ben Whittle

Ben WhittleComment left on: 31 October 2018 at 1:33 pm

Lizanne

Whilst infrared panels are certainly "efficient" in that they turn nearly all the electricity they use into heat - that doesn't mean they are green. It's still more envirnmentally friendly to use gas, oil or heat pumps than direct electric heating.

The benefit of infrared heating is that you only use it when you want it (assuming its manually turned on not timed) and onlys use it in the rooms where it is turned on. If you did the same thing with central heating it would be greener

Thermal mass does not equal insulation - it just slows down heat transfer

 

report abuse

snozwangle

snozwangleComment left on: 31 October 2018 at 12:08 pm

Tim's various experiences are all too common, especially electricity retailers not believing energy savings after fabric improvement and renewables installation.

Naturally, they rely on computer algorithms to try and trip us up (charge us too much), but the algorithms are far too simplistic to be realistic when bespoke improvements are made to the energy performance of a dwelling.

This failure to reflect reality not only applies to consumption, it applies to FIT payments for solar PV generation too. I have been told several times by my FIT scheme administrator that my regular generation reports are too high. I wouldn't be surprised to find that the algorithm they are using to produce a benchmark is based on insolation levels in Scotland - Kent is somewhat sunnier!

report abuse

Lizanne

LizanneComment left on: 31 October 2018 at 12:05 pm

I had a similar experience with my 200-year-old mid-terraced cottage in Cornwall, whereby the algorithm to produce an EPC couldn't take into account that the 2ft-thick external and internal walls contributed thermal mass and my wall "mirrors" in all rooms were in fact Infra-Red heating panels providing extremely efficient and cost-effective room heating (especially as we had a Solar PV installation on the rear roof) so that the (pre-existing) gas fires in the lounge and dining room were just for "effect". 

I was "marked down" for not having a condensing boiler - even though I had no central heating???? - the on-demand multipoint water heater was all that was needed to supply kitchen and bathroom taps.

We went to a great deal of trouble to future-proof our home for our retirement and now find it is misunderstood and unappreciated by prospective buyers :(

report abuse

Leave a comment

You must log in to make a comment. If you haven't already registered, please sign up as a company or an individual, then come back and have your say.